Upon the former defender stepped into the role as the club's head coach in January, he faced little time to get acclimated. A packed run of games signified a phased integration to his team was impossible.
Spanish media pointed out the challenges he would encounter, especially overseeing a locker room full of some of soccer's largest egos.
But establishing positive connections with the footballers was not a concern for the former Anfield defender.
"That is not something that concerns me a lot," Arbeloa said at his first news conference.
Eight weeks since, he states those rapports are strengthening and the results on the pitch are following.
Forging Bonds
In March, the Madrid boss led his side to victories against clubs coached by elite coaches: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, the Catalan's Manchester City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Los Merengues remain four points behind the Spanish league pace-setters Barcelona, with a potentially decisive Clasico in May, while their European run continues with a quarter-final tie against the German giants.
The team's form are on the up and the dynamic between the manager and squad are developing.
"I'm getting to know the individuals increasingly," commented the head coach after his team's 3-2 victory against local foes Atletico Madrid last week.
"I arrived at a juncture when I almost had little time to work with the players, to understand where they operated best, and to see how they mixed with each other."
He acknowledged the timing of his arrival posed unique obstacles.
"In my case, it's challenging to come mid-season and observe how the team works, and that is precisely what has transformed over these two months," he continued.
"Now I understand my players as individuals and footballers, where I can extract the best display from them, and where I can tweak things."
Praise for Vinicius Jr
A key individual excelling under the new manager is Vinicius Jr.
He has started 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches in charge, with his scoring rate also seeing a dramatic uptick - he has found the back of the net 11 times under Arbeloa, as opposed to managing just six in 27 outings under his predecessor.
The coach has concentrated on bolstering the forward's self-belief, urging him to play freely and express himself rather than limiting him in terms of tactics.
"I'm lucky to have Vini, he's adored by the supporters. We want to see the Vini who has fun on the pitch, who laughs, who dances… that's the Vini I want to see," Arbeloa stated in his first press conference as manager.
This philosophy stands in opposition to rumors of tension under Alonso, with Vinicius muttering "I'm going to leave this club" after being taken off in October's match against Barcelona.
The new boss has openly defended him, making clear he is fully backed by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous players, if not the deadliest, in the world and he embodies what a this club's star is," stated Arbeloa.
The Brazilian put negotiations about his long-term prospects in abeyance last off-season but, last week, he affirmed his loyalty clear.
"I'm only focused on this club and staying here for a long time," he told the press before his national team's friendly match with France.
Fede Valverde Regains Top Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's level has also improved dramatically since Arbeloa arrived.
Under the previous coach, he registered three goals and seven assists from 31 games.
Ever since Arbeloa's appointment, Valverde has started all 17 of his games, scoring seven times and providing five key passes.
A major reason has been a positional shift back into midfield.
During Alonso's spell, Valverde at times struggled to secure a regular place in his preferred position, being deployed in unusual roles such as full-back.
While the choice was in part because of injuries to other players, his frustration was obvious. "I was not made to be a right-back," he said.
However, now, restored to his natural habitat, the midfielder is thriving.
He has scored six strikes in just a 30-day period, featuring a hat-trick against City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 win over Atletico Madrid.
Fresh Faces, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's experience as head coach of Real Madrid's B team has made blending young players into the senior side feel seamless, so it was expected to expect him to give promising youngsters chances.
This occurred particularly when Real Madrid played Elche earlier this month and Arbeloa provided opportunities to six youth team graduates.
One player, in especial, has quickly broken through as one of the manager's most talented disciples.
Being only 18 years of age and 226 days, he made history as the most youthful footballer in the club's records to begin a match twice in the European Cup knockout stages, breaking Vinicius' milestone by 10 days.
Asked what it meant to see five academy graduates on the pitch, he couldn't mask his pride.
"I believe I can die happy after a evening like tonight," he stated.
"I was just talking to two of them, who were the first players I coached when they were very young, and to be able to give them the opportunity to play at the Santiago Bernabeu is a fantastic achievement for me."
Although Arbeloa might be familiar with the Castilla players, he acknowledges injuries have restricted his exposure